Health policy has opened up a major front of criticism against the Government over the last year. In leaders’ questions on 1 July, Micheál Martin rounded on James Reilly for refusing to restore bariatric surgery at St Vincent’s University Hospital. Twenty operations had been carried out at the hospital this year, before the Minister’s decision, but 200 people are on the waiting list for surgery.
“It is not good enough to say, as the Minister is saying, that it is tough on a patient that he or she is now morbidly obese, he cannot and will not do anything for the patient, and the next operation will be in 2015,” Martin stated. The Taoiseach regretted if the language used by the Minister “was deemed to be callous or uncaring” and responded: “It is simply a case of not having funding available to be able to do all that one needs or might like to do just now.”
Later in the session, Ceann Comhairle Seán Barrett interrupted Gerry Adams for following up a question on Cabinet committees with another on water services. “A habit has grown whereby we deal with four or five questions in the entire hour because we stray into other areas,” Barrett lamented. “The result is we never get through the agenda.”
Caoimhghín Ó Caoláin, meanwhile, used Sinn Féin’s last debating slot before the recess to highlight shortcomings in mental health services. The mental health of each citizen, he said, should be seen “as a positive resource that contributes to our general social, cultural and economic well-being.”
A damning critique of government policy came from Fine Gael backbencher James Bannon. “The system is in poor shape, starved of funding while neglecting thousands of people across the country each year,” he warned, adding that this failure “has overburdened emergency beds, crowded our jails, and left untreated patients to fend for themselves on our streets.”
In closing the debate, then Minister of State Alex White noted that deputies raised the need to balance change – particularly regarding safety and quality – against genuine concerns at a local level. He saw a need for continuous improvement and concluded: “There is no reason people in this country suffering from mental health problems cannot have the same modern, high quality service that works so well elsewhere.”
4 July saw Labour TD Kevin Humphreys introduce his Local Government (Amendment) Bill 2014 which would give the Dublin local authorities a new timeframe – up to 31 December 2016 – to agree on a proposal for a directly elected city mayor. “It would mean that we could possibly have a plebiscite for a directly elected mayor with the referendum next year,” he added.
The position “should not be a matter of patronage or rewarding those leaving the Oireachtas or Cabinet” and also “most certainly should not be used as a means of removing an unpopular Minister who is lowering the Government’s poll ratings.”
Reminding the Government of her contacts, Creighton added that “my colleagues in the Swedish Government inform me that they consult with the opposition as a matter of course” and the appointment is made by consensus.
The cancellation of the Garth Brooks concerts naturally made an appearance with Micheál Martin noting the “air of disbelief … about the fact what would have been a major economic project in its own right will not be proceeding.”
Following on from Joan Burton’s elevation as Tánaiste, the Dáil debated the appointment of the new ministers to the Government on 11 July.
“We are not just gritting our teeth and keeping the head down and surviving, but also hoping we can get to live our lives in the way people would expect,” Enda Kenny remarked. Burton saw a “vital window of opportunity [which] must not be lost” as citizens “now must feel the benefits of the recovery in their lives.”
Micheál Martin passed on warm personal congratulations but added that “the core strategy, the core unfairness and the core reality of spin and broken promises remain unchanged.” Gerry Adams reiterated his call for a general election. The appointments were approved by 93 votes to 33.
On a fitting note, members paid tribute to Norah White who was retiring after administering the Dáil restaurant for 48 years and also clerk Padraic Donlon, who is often seen sitting in front of Ceann Comhairle during debates.
The Dáil adjourned on 17 July, to sit again on 17 September.
Seanad Éireann continued for a day longer, closing with a debate on the Gaza and Ukrainian conflicts.
David Norris emotively demanded sanctions against Israel but Maurice Cummins took great pride in the State’s neutrality on Middle Eastern matters: “Bombs and rockets will not build peace and security. It is only through hearts and minds and dialogue that a secure peace can be established.” The House also returns on 17 September.
Pre-recess rush of new laws
The month of July also saw 16 acts signed into legislation at the Áras, which can be categorised into three groups.
Firstly, there are those setting up new State bodies i.e. the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, Court of Appeal, Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission, Shannon Group, and Strategic Banking Corporation. The Environmental Protection Agency also takes on the functions of the dissolved Radiological Protection Institute and the National Treasury Management Agency’s remit is reconstituted.
Secondly, significant policy changes are introduced such as the whistleblowers’ legislation (Protected Disclosures Act 2014), free GP care for children aged under six, and equal treatment between self-employed men and women applying for social security benefits.
The third group covers administrative changes, primarily unique identifier numbers in the Health Service and a single health budget vote buy also amendments to the laws on housing rent, employment permits and friendly, industrial and provident societies. The clerk-assistants of Dáil and Seanad Éireann are also enabled to perform the functions of their respective clerks when a vacancy or absence arises.